There are a lot of origins in URDF, making them bit confusing for me.
Before I decided to ask this question, I've done research on the forum and wiki post, including these posts: URDF and frames of reference URDF wiki
I've also tried to alter code from this tutorial to see how the alteration will change the pose of the robots. I drew couple of conclusions, but still not really sure about them
Please help me to clarify these things:
Every link has a reference of frame (and including with it an origin). By default the frame's origin of the link is located at the origin of the world.
We can custom the frame's origin of each link using the
<origin>tag inside<joint>element. For example:<joint name="joint1" type="continuous"> <parent link="link1"/> <child link="link2"/> <origin xyz="0 ${width} ${height1 - axel_offset}" rpy="0 0 0"/> <axis xyz="0 1 0"/> <dynamics damping="0.7"/>
The code above will position the frame's origin of link2(child) at the location and orientation specified by xyz and rpy components with respect to the link1(parent).
This frame's origin of each link is used as a reference for each link. The visual's ,collision's, and inertial's origins of the link will be defined with respect to the link's reference frame.
VISUAL's origin. This is to position the visual of a link w.r.t to the link's reference frame. The link's visual origin is attached to its center of shape (not center of mass, but mid of the link) -> I drew this conclusion from playing with this tutorial ,but I'm still not sure. The center of link is easily interpreted when the links are simple shapes like box or ball. But, what if the shape is an arbitrary shape? Where is the center of the shape that is attached with the visual's origin in this case?
COLLISION's origin. I think this is pretty much the same with visual's origin with the only difference that this is for the collision shape(collision shape can be different from visual shape). Collision's origin is attached to its center of the collision shape? Same question like before, what if the shape is arbitrary? where will the mid of shape be?
INERTIAL's origin. This is to specify the location of the center of mass , which depends on the mass distribution,of the link. Like the rest, intertial's origin is defined w.r.t the link's frame. Changing inertial's origin will not affect robot's appearance. for example, if we have a ball, to place the ball above the ground, what is required is to specify the visual's z origin = radius value. If the ball is homogeneous, then the inertial's z origin is also the radius. Otherwise, we can change the inertial's origin, and it will not affect the location of the ball, only the center of mass location is affected.
Sorry for the long question. Please confirm my statements OR correct any mistakes. Thank you
Originally posted by alienmon on ROS Answers with karma: 582 on 2017-08-22
Post score: 0
Original comments
Comment by David Lu on 2017-08-28:
You may find these tutorials more helpful than the gazebo-based ones: http://wiki.ros.org/urdf/Tutorials/
Comment by alienmon on 2017-08-28:
@David Lu Thanks for your suggestion.I actually just did those tutorials couple days ago. It seems to me that they confirm the statements I wrote in this post. However, it still doesn't answer some of my questions like on point 2 and 3.
