1
$\begingroup$

I am building a Hobby-weight robot and my weapon of choice is a spinning disk at the front.

As regards the disk I was thinking of buying commercial (grinder-type) disks and change type of disk depending on the "enemy's" chassis construction material. So for instance I would have an aluminum cutting disk if the enemy's chassis is made of aluminum and so on.

First question is therefore; do such disks do the job in practise (or break, fail to cut?)

Secondly, should I use a brushed or brush-less motor for the disk? I actually have ESCs for both but sort of feel a brushed motor will give me more torque while a brush-less motor might give me more speed. So which is more important speed or torque?

I do know - from my uncle who uses metal lathes - that machines that cut metal usually spin at a slower speed (drills, cutting wheels etc)- indeed he likes to say that metal working machines are safer than wood-working ones partially for this reason.

But I am a newbie and really would like to have an effective weapon if possible and breaking or not-cutting disks do not make such a weapon!

Also is it normal practise to use one battery for everything (drive and weapon) or have two separate batteries?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ This is as much a question about machining as it is about robotics. Steel can be cut with abrasive saws (like angle grinders), but aluminum not so much -- it melts and sticks to the abrasive surface, which makes the cutting less effective. Many times, you can cut aluminum successfully using a saw blade designed for wood. $\endgroup$ – Ian Oct 15 '14 at 14:58
  • $\begingroup$ The commercial disk I bought is intended to cut aluminium, but the best thing I can do is trial it on a bit of scrap aluminium I have handy; I also have wood type ones which look much more menacing due to the larger teeth but may be less effective. I will run some speed experiments this weekend with different motors and will also try to cut through aluminium. If push comes to shove I will have a disk made out of cast iron or mild steel for me but I still have the problem of the motor. Maybe I should just buy an in-runner brushless for a r/c car or heli and use that.. $\endgroup$ – Galahad II Oct 15 '14 at 20:38
  • $\begingroup$ I abandoned the disk and went for a drum with spikes. The "drum" is a printer rod (made of bright mild steel (BMS)and is 1.5 cm in diameter). Along the length I drilled out and threaded 9 x 5 mm holes and inserted spikes (cut from a 5 mm diameter BMS threaded rod). Locknuts on both ends completed the job. The drum fits into ball-bearings set in alum blocks. The motor is an standard brushless one and is connected to the drum/rod using 2 pulleys and an O ring for slippage / avoid high stall currents. It is also assigned to a variable channel on the r/c so that I can freely adjust the speed. $\endgroup$ – Galahad II Jan 16 '15 at 12:01
1
$\begingroup$

Well grinding machines in general use really high cutting speeds, so a very high revolution speed. At a metal lathe it is pretty easy to get the force of your tool onto the workpiece. In a robo-fight it's actually not that easy, so i suggest very high speed. More like an angle grinder

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Ah yes that makes sense. So speed is the thing then. $\endgroup$ – Galahad II Oct 15 '14 at 20:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.